Idle Minds and Wagging Tongues: Conversation in Anna Karenina :: Essays Papers

Idle Minds and Wagging Tongues confabulation in Anna KargonninaPerhaps one of the most striking scenes in Anna K arnina is that of slit and Levins silent declarations of love to each other, etched out mysteriously in chalk on a card table, with each mind innately the exact words the other was saying (362). With the relationship mingled with Kitty and Levin serving as Tolstoys model for a loaded and successful love, it appears odd that such a relationship should be founded on silence, and in such sharp contrast to the chatter of Society surround the couple at the party. How then are we to understand the significance of talk in the novel, if the most sincere relationships and understandings are not founded upon dialogue, but on unspoken knowledge? Entire subplots and themes are conveyed through conversations between the charactersthe nestling problem and farm management, religion, marriage and faithfulness. Everyone is trying to grasp what a respectable life is, but the ideas expressed in conversation, however, appear quite a lot to contradict twain the inner monologue of the characters and their actions, or fall pathetically short of expressing the power of the feelings of characters. For most of the characters, neither Society banter nor sharp discourse does justice to their real passions, and even personal exchanges are steeped in insincerity. Unless they find a means to express their passions some other way, they are doomed to a life of dissatisfaction at best, or a tragic end at worst.Within the opening conflict of the novelStivas affair with the French governess and his wifes reaction when learning of itTolstoy stolon presents this tension between honesty and speech. Before Dolly and Oblonskys exchanges, Tolstoy interposes a short confrontation between Oblonsky and his son, Grisha. Oblonsky is conscious of not caring as much for the boy as for the girl, but does his best to treat them both alike (7). Although he says, Good morning to Grisha, Ob lonskys words are insufficient to mask his inner feelings, and his actions betray him through a inhuman smile (7). Grisha, significantly, does not reply. To reply with some pleasantness would be to impact that Oblonsky was sincere in his greeting, and Grisha is too nave to use speech to do anything but to tell the truth. Short of accusing his father of not pleasing him, which he is already old enough to understand would be in all inappropriate, he can only remain silent.